Skip to main content

Beta testing. Real payments work with crypto only. Card payments (Stripe) are test-only for now.

Back to news
Soccer
1 min read

Manchester United's confusing penalty area conundrum suggests Michael Carrick is doing a very good job

Manchester United’s points tally tells the story of a disappointing start to the season and pressure is building on Michael Carrick. The 1-1 draw to ...
Manchester United's confusing penalty area conundrum suggests Michael Carrick is doing a very good job

Manchester United’s points tally tells the story of a disappointing start to the season and pressure is building on Michael Carrick.

The 1-1 draw to Fulham this week means that Manchester United have collected just five points from their opening five Premier League matches.

In particular, the lack of effort in United’s performances is concerning. United were outrun by Fulham, and the Red Devils are also yet to keep a clean sheet in the Premier League.

So the general mood around the fanbase is bleak, but one statistic offers some hope about how United have been playing.

What is your INSTANT REACTION to seeing United's placing in the Premier League table after five games?

This season, there have been complaints about United’s poor attacking output, as well as the disorganised defending at the back.

So it is extremely confusing to know that United have actually been the best team in the Premier League at attacking the opposition’s penalty area, AND the best at defending their own.

According to Opta, Manchester United have had more touches in the opposition box than any other Premier League team this season (182).

They have also seen their opponents have the fewest inside their own penalty area (92).

It is a head-scratching stat. United have had the most touches in the opposition box yet have only scored eight goals in the Premier League.

Similarly, United have allowed the fewest touches in their penalty area, yet have conceded eight goals.

Those figures suggest Carrick is putting United players in strong positions, yet they aren’t delivering in the most important moments.

Carrick’s job is to set up a system that allows United to attack the opposition box. It’s then up to players to finish chances, and so far United have been extremely wasteful.

The tactical setup is clearly also denying chances to opponents, but there have been too many individual mistakes that have led to goals.

Comments0

Your sport, all in one place

Soccer

Follow the stories, and hear of new ones in your feed and notifications.

Picks to explore

All Soccer picks

About this story and its source

Who published the story, when it came out, and where to read more.

It was published on September 21, 2026 and last updated on October 9, 2026. The time of the story is shown in your own time zone on the page.

Open the Soccer news for more stories, or see the matches with analyst picks and the list of analysts to compare their records before you buy a pick.